RE ; MAC11 update
rhouck at neo.rr.com
Tue Sep 9 19:37:39 PDT 2008
I have read through the suggestions on SJM's site, and feel that I have
tested or eliminated things sufficiently, but since I have not yet found the
problem, I am obviously missing something. Opening the ECU was one of the
earliest things I did, since the problems started at a rainy track event. I
found no evidence of moisture or water tracks, but dried it out in the sun
just to be sure. After no improvement, I ordered a spare ECU and distributor
I have at least two of each of the major ignition and mechanical components,
and I have tried about every combination of ECUs,plugs, wires, dist caps and
rotors, complete distributors, coils, flywheel RPM and TDC sensors, knock
sensors, fuel filters, and COMPLETE ENGINES. Nothing so far changes the
situation except turning the distributor counter clockwise.
It seems unlikely that I have two identically bad components, but maybe I
do. It also seems unlikely that both engines have a sheered key on the cam
or crank, but the relationship between the distributor rotor and the TDC
trigger is good enough for starting but not for running at higher revs. The
ECU is getting full voltage during the problems, and I also have confirmed
ground (don't remember pin numbers now). As Ben says, ignition seems to be
satisfied enough to start and run properly for the first 25% of the RPM
Cody, I have some very loud exhaust backfires (3" from turbo back with no
cat), but others come back into the intake system. I have been concerned
that I may damage my turbo or intercooler plumbing. This indicates to me
that the timing is getting confused at some RPM, or that the plug is firing
at an improper time because of arching. When I changed plugs last week
(again) the Bosch's had a dry carbon coating, but IMO nothing out of the
ordinary for an engine running at low speeds. New plugs are NGK's, but
results are the same.
about to give up
----- Original Message -----
From: "Louis-Alain Richard" <laraa at sympatico.ca>
To: "'Rick Houck'" <rhouck at neo.rr.com>; <cody at 5000tq.com>; "'Ben Swann'"
<benswann at verizon.net>
Cc: <quattro at audifans.com>; "'P Cole'" <pcolegrps at comcast.net>; "'Ado
Sigal'" <a.sigal at bluewin.ch>
Sent: Monday, September 08, 2008 11:11 PM
Subject: RE ; MAC11 update
Well Rick, I have no answer to your turbo question, but before looking for a
mechanical failure, which is always possible but usually shows some
evidence, please complete the ignition route first.
If I remember well, you never mentioned any diagnostic at the MAC-11 ECU
itself, just that there was no codes ? I would open the ECU to see if
there's any water or corrosion in there. If not, I am sure there is a way to
test the boost pressure transducer in situ without an oscilloscope but with
a mighty-vac and an adjustable timing light, or something like that.
I once had to find a running problem on a friend's urQuattro, and an ECU
swap was the solution. But we arrived there after completing the whole
official diagnostic procedure, which is long and fastidious, and the ECU
replacement was the very last step.
> -----Message d'origine-----
> I think things are pointing to a wiring problem, but have a couple of
> questions first: Could a turbo that doesn't spin as easily as when it was
> new cause backfires? My Garret GT2871 ball bearing turbo still spins up
> I can see when the cone filter is off), and I can hear it coast down after
> shutdown, but it is not quite as smooth as when it was new 3 years ago. I
> have not checked end play, but it certainly is not enough to cause any
> contact with the housing. I can't get enough RPM to get the boost up much,
> but it does get started up the dial before the backfires start.
> I don't have an o-scope, but I think it is time to find someone who does.
More information about the quattro